THIS MIGHT SURPRISE YOU
The answer
Matthew alone. The chief priests ask Pilate to secure the tomb, "otherwise, his disciples may go and steal him away" (Matthew 27:64). The stone is sealed and a guard is posted (27:66). The guards shake at the angel (28:4). They are paid to say the disciples stole the body (28:11-15). Mark, Luke and John have no guard.
Why it’s interesting
The New Oxford Annotated Bible, a study Bible, says Pilate's guard means Roman soldiers, not Temple police. The scholar Raymond Brown sees the whole guard story as apologetics, an argument defending Christian belief against attacks on the resurrection. Matthew's own ending says the story of the stolen body "is still told among the Judeans to this day" (Matthew 28:15).
Scholarly consensus
Learn the Bible.
Not just the stories, but the history, authorship, and scholarship behind it.