DID YOU KNOW?
The answer
The Greek word for "from above" also means "again." The play works in Greek, the language John wrote in. It does not work in Aramaic, the language Jesus spoke.
Why it’s interesting
That is why the scene fails the test of fitting Jesus's own setting. If the conversation happened, it could not have gone exactly as John tells it.
Scholarly consensus
Learn the Bible.
Not just the stories, but the history, authorship, and scholarship behind it.