THIS MIGHT SURPRISE YOU
The answer
Bethlehem (Matthew 2:1; Luke 2:4-7). Both nativity accounts agree on the town, even as they get there by very different routes.
Why it’s interesting
Matthew's family already lives in Bethlehem and later moves to Nazareth; Luke's starts in Nazareth and travels to Bethlehem for a census. Same destination, two different journeys.
Scholarly consensus
You can know the Bible.
Not just the stories, but the history, authorship, and scholarship behind it.